Forget Cape Cod — New England's Affordable Alternative Has Gorgeous Beaches An Hour From Boston

Add Explore on Google:

There's good reason Cape Cod is popular with visitors. Long, pristine beaches and bustling harbor towns attract thousands in summer, all longing to soak up some of its New England charm, vibrant culture, and mouthwateringly good seafood. But anyone who's been will know all of those things can come with a hefty price tag. For a more affordable and quieter escape, consider visiting Plum Island instead. The wildly beautiful beaches are equally as appealing in winter as in summer. The birds certainly think so, with more than 300 species enjoying the protection that Parker River National Wildlife Refuge and Sandy Point State Reservation provide on the southern end of the island.

Located roughly an hour's drive north of Boston, the 11-mile-long barrier island on Massachusetts' North Shore is named after the wild beach plums that grow among the sand dunes. With beaches as the main attraction, most activities take place along the wild Atlantic shoreline, with salt marshes and tidal creeks making up much of the rest of the maritime landscape. Considerably less developed than Cape Cod, Plum Island suits a different kind of visitor, one who enjoys the relative tranquility and quieter pastimes of hiking, birdwatching, and surfcasting, or paddling in the calmer waters of Plum Island Sound.

While accommodation isn't necessarily cheaper than Cape Cod, especially in summer, the focus is on inexpensive nature-based activities rather than costly attractions. And if you need somewhere a bit more lively, the charming coastal city of Newburyport is just over the bridge. Driving is the easiest way to reach Plum Island if coming from Boston, the world's most beautiful winter city. Once there, Refuge Road runs almost from one end of the island to the other, with regular parking lots and beach access along the way.

Plum Island beaches and activities

Newbury Beach is popular for swimming and surfing, and you can't beat watching the sun rise over the Atlantic Ocean. Up at Plum Island Point, on the northern tip of the island where the Merrimack River meets the ocean, you can watch boats come and go or head out on one yourself. Captain's Fishing Parties organizes fishing trips and cruises, and its sister company Newburyport Whale Watch offers responsible whale watching trips with the chance to see humpback, fin, and minke whales feeding in the Gulf of Maine between May and October.

Located along the Atlantic Flyway, Parker River National Wildlife Refuge is teaming with birdlife. A vehicle day pass costs $5, and there are several trails where you can look out for piping plovers, sandpipers and hundreds of other resident and migratory birds. The Hellcat Boardwalk Trail is particularly rewarding, especially in spring and fall, with wheelchair accessible walkways and viewing platforms overlooking the beaches, salt marshes, and maritime forest. Some sections close during nesting season, from spring into late summer, so check the website for exact dates. At the southernmost tip, Sandy Point State Reservation has even more stretches of golden sand, but with limited parking, spaces fill up quickly in summer.

The western side of the island, overlooking Plum Island Sound and the Great Marsh estuary has much more sheltered waters, and kayaking and paddleboarding are great ways to explore the network of tidal creeks. Coastal Adventure Rental has kayaks from $150 and paddleboards from $180. The shoreline is particularly stunning at sunset, and seals occasionally make an appearance. Check tides and the weather forecast before heading out onto the water, and arm yourself with some bug spray to ward off mosquitoes and the vicious greenhead flies, which are particularly bloodthirsty from July through mid-August.

More things to do on Plum Island

Plum Island has a long maritime history. The mouth of the Merrimack River was a notoriously difficult stretch of water to navigate due to shifting sandbars and strong currents, meaning shipwrecks were frequent. Several lighthouses have been and gone, destroyed by violent storms or lost due to coastal erosion. But in 1898, Newburyport Harbor Lighthouse was built and still stands today on the northern side. You can visit the grounds year-round, but free tours of the interior are only held on certain dates by Friends of Plum Island Light.

While facilities are few and far between, the lack of commercial development is Plum Island's charm. Bar Plum Island Soap Company and its wonderfully fragrant skincare collections, you'll need to head into Newburyport if you want to do a spot of shopping. You'll still find a decent meal, though, and you can't visit Plum Island without chomping down on a lobster roll. Bob Lobster serves up one of the best for around $30. Open year-round and winner of several awards, the unassuming seafood shack has been serving up fresh, home-cooked dishes since 2001. Alternatively, Mad Martha's Island Café is a relaxing spot for breakfast and brunch, open all year.

There's no denying the appeal of waking up to Atlantic views and stepping straight onto the beach to catch the sunrise and feel the sand between your toes. But one thing Plum Island has in common with Cape Cod is that holiday rentals and hotel accommodation don't come cheap. Blue – Inn on the Beach is a popular option, offering direct access to the ocean and beautifully decorated suites and cottages. You'll find a few Airbnb options, but nearby Newburyport offers much more choice, and you're more likely to find a better deal if staying inland or visiting out of peak season.